Shireen Abu Akleh
Featured Israel Palestine Shireen Abu Akleh

A history of lies: Lying deliberately is Israel’s modus operandi in the West Bank

A particularly affronting and contemptible message Israel is trying to communicate to the world following the outrageous crime of murdering  Shireen Abu Akleh two days ago would try to convince us that Israel is a law-abiding country where transparency prevails and foul play has no chance.

Related Article: Israeli Force Assaults Participants in the Funeral of Shireen Abu Akleh.

This is not merely a catch-22 lie. It is a rather deliberate, rehearsed, and carefully considered a misrepresentation of the truth, intended to deceive and mislead.

In fact, I would exaggerate very little if I said that “professional lying” constitutes the ultimate modus operandi of the Israeli army’s discourse related to the brutal occupation and the criminal treatment meted out to the Palestinians.

Israel claims it respects press freedom and allows Palestinian journalists and cameramen a wide margin of freedom of movement.

The truth of the matter, however, is that the Israeli security establishment doesn’t distinguish between Palestinians on the basis of their professions, passports, religions, and political affiliations. Their lives are equally expendable and their blood too cheap.

Related Article: Israel has killed 55 Palestinian journalists since 2000

Some people might be prompted to think that Israeli occupation soldiers might display a certain modicum of discretion or leniency, or even civility,  in treating a Palestinian who has American citizenship.

Actually, I can state rather solemnly and quite candidly that in many cases, occupation soldiers manning roadblocks and checkpoints throughout the occupied territories often single out Palestinians who are US passport holders for harsher humiliation tactics, e.g. by making them wait long hours before letting them go.

In several cases, Israeli troops actually shot and killed Palestinians having American citizenship.

I asked an Israeli friend to explain this strange behavior, given Israel’s enormous dependence on Washington. The Jewish journalist said, “Israel wants to demonstrate to the Palestinians that none of them has immunity or protection from the Israeli grip, even if he or she holds the American passport.”

In fact, Sherine Abu Akleh was not the only Palestinian holder of American citizenship to be graphically killed by the Israeli army.

On 4 January, 78- year- Omar Asaad, who also held US citizenship died in Israeli custody after being arrested and harassed by the Israeli army.

Israel begrudgingly carried out an investigation into his death, reportedly after receiving a strongly-worded message from the Biden administration.

I am certain that the declared Israeli willingness to carry out a formal enquiry into Sherine’s murder, wouldn’t have been announced had Sherine been unequipped with the US shield, which didn’t help her anyway.

Lying like breathing

As a journalist and eyewitness to the Israeli army’s behavior since my return from the States in 1983, I can testify that the Israeli army and the entire security establishment lie as often as You and I breathe the oxygen of life. This is by no means a one-time occurrence, it is rather a prevailing culture, a real way of life.

I am sure veteran Palestinian journalists remember how the Israeli army spokesperson was phrasing his accounts of dispersing Palestinian demonstrations during the first intifada.

The army account would look like this: IDF soldiers came under a volley of stones by Palestinian stone-throwers. The soldiers shot into the air and a number of Palestinians were injured or killed.”

In other instances, this journalist saw an IDF officer place a knife beside the body of a Palestinian teenager the occupation soldiers had just killed in downtown Hebron to give the impression that the boy was trying to stab a soldier.

Also Read: Israeli occupation forces killed 3 Palestinian men in separate shootings.

Israeli occupation soldiers don’t learn only how to shoot and murder Palestinian civilians. They also learn how to conceal incriminating evidence. And when the IDF faced negative publicity as a result of a particularly outrageous crime, like burying people alive with dirt and mud while leaving their heads uncovered, the soldiers involved are rebuked harshly, not for committing the crime itself but rather for having failed to make sure that no photographer or cameraman was watching.

Also Read: Israeli Occupation Killed 53 Palestinian since the Start of 2022.

This is the reason 99% of the hideous crimes and savagery inflicted on innocent Palestinians are not investigated or followed up, which means these serious violations go into oblivion.

Killing knowingly and killing deliberately

Several years ago, I interviewed an IDF spokeswoman who is now Israel’s ambassador in a major Arab capital.

I asked her to explain the large civilian casualties among Palestinians as a result of IDF gunfire. She said, “all armies make mistakes and the IDF was no exception”.

I told her a mistake is made once, twice, ten times. But when it happens so often, it means that killing protesters is a policy.

She said the policy of the IDF was to avoid targeting civilians deliberately.

But the IDF kills these people knowingly, I asked.

She said knowingly yes, but deliberately no.

But, please I said, could you explain the difference because frankly, I see no difference between killing knowingly and killing deliberately.

Eventually, she said. Khalid, you ask too many questions, and my time is limited.

Finally, I believe it would be gullible and naïve to count on the Zionist regime to carry out a transparent and credible investigation. Criminals wouldn’t indict themselves.

Moreover, we should know by now that one doesn’t seek justice in the dens of thieves nor seeks safety in snake holes. In the final analysis, Israel is a criminal, liar and thief. It is time all honest men and women around the world know Israel as she really is.

Khaled Amayreh
Khalid Amayreh (Arabic: خالد عمايرة‎‎, b. 1957 Hebron) is a Palestinian journalist based in Dura, near Hebron, West Bank. He is an award-winning reporter who has contributed hundreds of articles to the Al-Jazeera English website from the Occupied West Bank. His field includes, inter alia, strategic studies with emphasis on the Arab world, Iran after the Shah, the Arab-Israeli conflict, contemporary Islamic movements, religious Zionism, comparative religion. Shiite Islam and failure of democratization in the Arab world. He received most of his formal education in the US where he obtained two degrees in journalism, a BA from the University of Oklahoma and a Master's degree in the same field from Southern Illinois University at Carbondale. He has published numerous studies and articles on a variety of subjects in both English and Arabic. He has also written five books. The title of his MA thesis in the US was “the religious Press in America and the Palestinian question from 1967-1983. Amayreh has worked for the following media: Middle East International, London, al-Jazeera English, Ahram Weekly (Cairo), UAE TV, and several other Arabic publications. Amayreh's sole agenda is to spread and disseminate the truth about the enduring Palestinian/Israeli conflict which seems to defy all peace efforts. Honesty are rectitude are paramount for him. Per him, unfortunately, this conflict is unlikely to be resolved in the foreseeable future or even during our lifetime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.